Duel to the Death Inside HIV-Infected
Discovery of Shadowy Enzyme and Its Infectivity
Nemesis May Prove Key Step in Defeating the Virus That Causes AIDS
By David Brown
Washington Post Staff Writer
Monday, March 8, 2004; Page A08
Most of the time, life with the AIDS virus appears to be a placid affair.
Except for the days immediately after infection, people fighting human
immunodeficiency virus (HIV) don't suffer the roller coaster of fevers or aches
typical of many infections. The debilitating symptoms of AIDS occur mostly at
the end, years after the virus has taken up residence in billions of cells.
AIDS virologists know, however, that appearances deceive. The body's fight
against HIV is steady and fierce. Rough estimates are that hundreds of millions
of cells called lymphocytes -- the immune system's foot soldiers -- die in the
struggle and are replaced each day.
The body mounts two broad forms of attack. Antibodies produced by the immune
system kill individual virus particles, called virions, before they can infect
cells. At the same time, killer lymphocytes hunt down and destroy their
unfortunate brethren already infected with HIV in order to prevent the virus
from making more virions inside them.
Both of those modes of attack take place outside cells in the vast battlefields
of bloodstream and lymph nodes. But it turns out they're not the only places
where the fight is underway.
In the last two years, AIDS researchers have discovered a much different
struggle that is waged in the quiet confines of the cell interior. There, it's a
cloak-and-dagger game between two individual molecules -- one produced by the
virus, the other by the infected cell.
This insight is one of biology's more exciting discoveries in years. It has shed
new light on the shadowy workings of "innate immunity," the body's
ancient, although far from primitive, form of defense. It has deepened
virologists' profound respect for HIV's wiles. At the same time, it has offered
a new, previously unrecognized target where the virus might be attacked by a
drug of the future.
The AIDS virus contains only nine genes. Molecular biologists have known for
many years that one of them enhances the virus's infectiousness. It was named
Vif, for "virion infectivity factor." But until recently, nobody
actually knew what it did.
Two years ago, researchers Ann M. Sheehy and Michael Malim at the University of
Pennsylvania School of Medicine began to answer that question. Much of what they
learned came from watching what happens when human lymphocytes -- HIV's
preferred target -- are infected with a mutant form of the virus that lacks Vif.
That work -- and that of laboratories following up on those findings -- has
uncovered an unusual sequence of events that were the topic of much discussion
last month at the 11th Retrovirus Conference, the annual midwinter AIDS meeting
in the United States.
It turns out that lymphocytes produce a substance that's been given the unwieldy
name APOBEC3G. It's a member of a family of enzymes whose job is to edit RNA or
DNA, the strands of genetic material that constitute genes.
The various APOBEC enzymes -- there are nearly a dozen -- make specific changes
in a gene's message. These are the equivalent of rewriting a word or two in a
paragraph. That, in turn, alters the gene's meaning in small but significant
This system of gene editing makes the storage of information more economical.
Genes whose messages differ by only a word or two don't have to be spelled out
separately in the cell's genome. Instead, the cell can store one version -- and
the minor variations can be created by editing that template once it's
transcribed, or copied.
APOBEC3G, however, is an editor grown tired of wearing green eyeshades and
thanklessly editing copy. APOBEC3G dreams of being a secret agent. It wants to
turn its pencil into a lethal weapon.
When an AIDS virus lacking Vif infects a lymphocyte, molecules of APOBEC3G
shadow the newly replicating virions. In a process that's not fully understood,
the enzyme slips inside the viral envelope just before the envelope is sealed
and the virion buds off from the cell.
When that virion attaches to another cell and infects it, the material it
unloads includes APOBEC3G.
Transcribing and copying its genes into the cell's DNA is an essential step in
HIV's replication. As the virus goes about this inside the newly infected cell,
APOBEC3G goes to work, too. It edits -- and edits and edits and edits. It edits
the viral DNA transcript to a point where the message is such an unreadable mess
that the cell tears it up. This stops replication and breaks the chain of
This, at least, is what happens in APOBEC3G's dreams. But it isn't what happens
in reality very often. That's because HIV virions lacking Vif don't exist in the
wild -- and for an obvious reason. They cannot make more of themselves when
APOBEC3G is around.
In reality, nearly all "wild-type" strains of HIV do have Vif. It is
HIV's own secret agent, evolved over time to neutralize APOBEC3G. Although many
details of the mechanism are still undiscovered, Vif appears to work this way:
As APOBEC3G trails a developing virion inside an infected cell, Vif -- which has
been made in the cell from one of HIV's genes during the replication process --
lies in wait for it. As the editing enzyme is just about to sneak into the viral
envelope, Vif intercepts it.
In a scene that would make the old Soviet KGB proud, this adventure-seeking
editor, clearly an amateur in a world of professionals, is calmly led away from
the budding virion.
Vif is quickly joined by other proteins named cullin, elongin and ubiquitin.
Together they lead the hapless enzyme into a cellular structure called a
proteosome -- the Room Where Very Bad Things Happen. There, quite literally,
APOBEC3G is liquidated.
How much this particular fight contributes to the body's war of attrition
against HIV is uncertain.
"It has been obvious during the recent years that we come down [to defeat],
but not without a fight," Didier Trono of the University of Geneva told the
scientists at the conference. "Even though we get outsmarted at the end, we
give a good game to the virus."
Armed with these insights, scientists are hoping to change the outcome of the
"I think there are tremendous therapeutic implications of this new
discovery," said Dana H. Gabuzda, a researcher at Harvard Medical School
and the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston.
If there were a way to block Vif from interfering with APOBEC3G, the editor
might be freed to go about its lethal work. A substance capable of doing that
might make a good AIDS drug. Gabuzda and members of her laboratory are hard at
work looking for one now.
How can we manifest peace on
earth if we do not include everyone (all races, all nations, all religions, both
sexes) in our vision of Peace?
The WorldPeace Banner
To order a WorldPeace Insignia lapel pin, go to: Order
To the John WorldPeace Galleries Page
To the WorldPeace Peace Page